Yesterday I prepared four different kinds of cookies, all in anticipation of National Cookie Day. Okay, okay, it was just part of my holiday baking, but it's an occasion I'm happy to celebrate (and what a coincidence that this falls around the time that everyone is baking their holiday treats). I wish I could say I hit all of the recipes out of the park, but alas some of the "Corked" Breton galettes got a little too brown on the bottom. I suppose I must sacrifice and leave those at home instead of putting them out on the cookie tray I am taking into the office later this week. The four cookies I made so far are:

- "Corked" Breton galettes from Dorie's Cookies by Dorie Greenspan
- Homemade Oreo cookies from BraveTart by Stella Parks
- Salted chocolate-cardamom cookies from Jew-ish by Jake Cohen
- Soft gingerbread tiles with rum butter glaze from Sweet by Yotam Ottlenghi and Helen Goh
- "Maple" pecan cookies (from a recipe I am currently developing)
The "Maple" pecan sandies have the quotation marks because I added a touch of fenugreek powder to them for a faintly maple flavor that accentuates the pecan flavor of the cookies. I think rolling them in maple sugar will be the next step but alas I don't have any on hand. Up next in my baking extravaganza I am contemplating the following:
- Stroopwafel from Dark Rye & Honeycake by Regula Ysewijn
- Salted rosemary shortbread from Sister Pie by Lisa Ludwinski
- Chocolate chunk and chip cookies from Bouchon Bakery by Thomas Keller and Sebastien Rouxel
- Tahini, almond and honey cookies (Tahinobiskoto) from Nistisima by Georgina Hayden
- Crispy iced oatmeal flats from Midwest Made by Shauna Sever
My biggest issue for a visually pleasing cookie tray is that these are, as cookies tend to be, somewhat monochromatic. The "corked" Breton galettes have a splash of red with their jam centers and I opted for a pink (strawberry) filling in the homemade Oreos to somewhat counteract this. I'm also thinking of using green sanding sugar to decorate the shortbread and perhaps putting sprinkles in the icing on the oatmeal cookies, but I'm open to suggestions. Do you have a go-to recipe for colorful cookies, other than Italian rainbow cookies? How is your holiday baking coming along?
CookShelf
4 comments
Kinhawaii
anya_sf
hillsboroks
SheilaS
I noticed that NYT cooking seemed to consider the colorful plate in their cookie selections this year. Sam Seneviratne's Technicolor Cookies are made with a positively psychedelic icing but I think I'd like them much better without.
Eric Kim's Matcha Latte cookies are green, under a cloud of ermine icing. Too much for me, though he allows that a dusting of powdered sugar can sub.
Sue Li has some adorable Neapolitan Checkerboard cookies and Sohla El-Waylly's Rainbow Rave Cookies are amply decorated with M&Ms and sprinkles.