Blame Alton Brown or perhaps even Marie Kondo for the backlash against kitchen tools that have only one use - unitaskers, as Brown calls them. The argument against them boils down to this: why take up valuable kitchen space for a tool that does only one thing? Sometimes, however, the item does that one thing so well that it becomes indispensable. So says Gray Chapman, who says that a butter dish is one such object.
Chapman says that even though a butter dish does not save her time or money, but it provides her with something that nothing else can, which is the promise of never having to "settle for a rock-hard, bread-mauling slab of butter-colored granite." It's also aesthetically pleasing.
While a butter dish doesn't rise to the level of absurdity of some unitasking items such as a selfie spoon, most people would not consider it an essential item. I share Chapman's love for the butter dish and have for years (when asked by my high school newspaper what my 'pet peeve' was, I immediately replied with 'cold butter').

However, I have a different unitasker that I just adore. It's the strawberry coring tool pictured above. After hauling home boxes of strawberries from the local U-pick farm, I immediately reach for this handy device as I prep the berries for jam making. I find it much quicker to use than a paring knife, as one flick does the job of removing all of the white part of the berry without lopping off any of the good stuff.
You probably have a tool or two lying in your kitchen cabinets or drawers that isn't practical but that you couldn't bear to part with. What is your favorite unitasking device?
CookShelf
10 comments
Jane
lkgrover
Achilz
Achilz
averythingcooks
eliza
I do have a Braun yogurt maker from the early 90's that I recently saw described elsewhere online as one of the most useless kitchen gadgets ever invented. I use it to make goat's milk yogurt...$2 of goat's milk produces enough yogurt to last at least a week, it's very easy to make, and saves about $6 since goat yogurt is quite pricey.
hillsboroks
kitchen_chick
Regarding cherry pitters: I pit from 30-50lbs of sour cherries in the summer. I use a paper clip for cherry pitting. I've found it to be faster than my cherry pitter.
sir_ken_g
MarciK